Refinish, reline or replace: the prices side by side
Four ways to deal with a worn tub, cheapest first. National market ranges, not our prices:
| Option | Market range |
|---|---|
| Bathtub inlayCovers the bottom of the tub only (Angi; This Old House gives the same range). | $100–$200 |
| Refinish or reglaze the tubAngi's 2026 range; $484 on average. | $337–$631 |
| Bathtub liner over the old tubThis Old House says $1,700 to $2,500; Angi says $2,700 to $10,200. | $1,700–$10,200 |
| Replace the tubAngi's 2026 range; $5,931 on average. A new surround adds $500 to $2,000. | $2,105–$9,759 |
On averages, refinishing costs $5,447 less: $484 against $5,931 to replace (Angi, from 4,360 projects). Angi puts replacement labor at $100 to $2,000, and removal and disposal at $150 to $4,500, more for a heavy cast-iron tub. The two sources on liners disagree widely, so get a liner priced for your tub before you compare.
When refinishing stops making sense
Houses here are old. In Belleville the median home was built in 1951, and 32.4% date from 1939 or earlier (Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024). Across Essex County the median is 1958, with 29.1% built in 1939 or earlier (Census Reporter). Angi notes that cast iron was the standard tub before fiberglass and can last 100 years or more with care. The national guides agree on when refinishing is not the answer:
- The tub leaks, is severely damaged or has large cracks. Angi says to consider replacing it.
- The tub is old, leaking or moldy. This Old House says refinishing it is not worth it.
- Major cracks, rust spots or deep scratches. This Old House says reglazing may not cover them.
- The tile is natural stone, which Angi says is often not recommended for reglazing.
- The damage is behind or under the tub: loose tile, soft walls, a spongy floor. A coating on the surface does not reach it.

Past that point the job is a remodel: the old tub or the surround comes out, the plumbing and the walls behind are opened and fixed, and new tile goes up over waterproofing. That is our bathroom remodeling work, published from $12,000 including material. Retiling the same 70 sq ft surround at our published tile labor of $10 to $20 and up a square foot is from $700 to $1,400 before the tile, the demolition and the backer board; reglazing it runs $280 to $840 at market rates. The bathroom remodel cost guide has the line items and a calculator.

Permits: refinishing needs none, relining is different
New Jersey's construction code lists the work it treats as ordinary maintenance: no permit, no inspection and no notice to the town (N.J.A.C. 5:23-2.7). For a bathtub and its tile, the rule says:
- Refinishing existing fixtures is ordinary maintenance (5:23-2.7(c)2ii, one of the rule's plumbing items). A tub is a plumbing fixture.
- Relining is not. The same line says relining fixtures is not ordinary maintenance, so a liner over the old tub falls outside the no-permit list. Ask your town's construction office what it needs.
- Swapping the tub for a similar one is ordinary maintenance only when the piping arrangement does not change (5:23-2.7(c)2x). Adding to, altering or relocating piping never is (5:23-2.7(b)6).
- Interior painting is ordinary maintenance (5:23-2.7(c)1i). The rule does not name tile reglazing separately.
Our New Jersey permit guide covers the bathroom work that does need one, and who files it.
Sales tax on refinishing
New Jersey taxes a contractor's labor on repairs and maintenance, and exempts it on most capital improvements (S&U-2, S&U-3). Neither bulletin names tub or tile refinishing. Their nearest examples:
- Taxed: fixing loose bath tiles is a repair, and repainting the interior of a house is maintenance. Repairs, the bulletins say, restore property to working condition without adding to its value or prolonging its life.
- Exempt: new bathroom fixtures and a new tiled bath are capital improvements, as is replacing all of the tiles with upgraded or improved materials. You give the contractor a completed Form ST-8, which only the property owner can issue.
- On taxable work the rate is 6.625%, charged on the labor. The contractor may not charge you sales tax on the materials and supplies.
- A lump-sum bill for taxable work that does not separate materials from labor is taxed on the whole amount (S&U-2).
So ask each bidder how the job is classified, and to show labor and materials on separate lines.
Fumes: what OSHA and EPA say
Refinishing commonly means removing the old finish, then applying a new coating, usually a synthetic finish such as polyurethane or epoxy, and it often involves methylene chloride, acids and isocyanates (OSHA and NIOSH hazard alert). The federal record:
- At least 14 worker deaths since 2000 related to refinishing tubs with methylene chloride strippers, by OSHA and NIOSH's 2013 count. OSHA's 2016 FatalFacts put it at 17 between 2000 and 2015.
- Exposure to as little as six ounces of a methylene chloride product has been enough to cause death. In a small bathroom the vapor collects in the tub and the worker's breathing zone (OSHA).
- OSHA's workplace limits are 25 parts per million over eight hours and 125 over any 15 minutes (29 CFR 1910.1052).
- Since November 22, 2019, methylene chloride may not be made, processed or sold for consumer paint and coating removal, and EPA encourages consumers to stop using any they still have (EPA).
- EPA's broader 2024 rule on methylene chloride was vacated by the Fifth Circuit in September 2026 (East Fork Enterprises v. EPA). EPA says the decision did not affect the 2019 consumer ban or OSHA's workplace limits.
Questions worth asking any refinisher before work starts:
- Which stripper and coating will you use, and does either contain methylene chloride?
- How will the bathroom be ventilated while you work and while the coating cures?
- Who should stay out of the room, and for how long?
- When can we use the tub again? Angi says the surface needs 24 to 48 hours to set and cure.
How long it lasts, and what the words mean
- A reglazed tub: 10 to 15 years (Angi). At least 10 years with proper care (This Old House).
- Reglazed tile: 10 to 15 years, less under high moisture and foot traffic (HomeGuide).
- The job: two to five hours for a standard tub, then 24 to 48 hours to set and cure (Angi).
- Care: non-abrasive, bleach-free cleaners only; stronger ones can eat away the new coating (This Old House).
Refinishing, reglazing and resurfacing are used for the same job. This Old House uses refinishing for the whole restoration and reglazing for the coating applied at the end, and calls resurfacing usually synonymous with refinishing.
Comparing refinishing bids
What the top phone results for “bathtub refinishing cost” in Belleville said on November 17, 2026:
- A Long Island, New York refinisher: about $480 on average, $300 to $700 in total.
- A Facebook post: refinishing normally under $400, against an average of $1,700 to $3,800 to remove and replace a tub.
- A refinishing company's repair guide: the factors that set the price, and no dollar figure.
None gave a New Jersey price, and none covered the tile, the permit line or the tax. Compare bids on the same questions:
- Is chip, crack and rust repair in the price, or extra?
- Is the tile surround included, and is grout repair priced?
- Is old caulk removed and the tub recaulked?
- What exactly does the written warranty cover, and what does it exclude?
- How is the job classified for sales tax, and are labor and materials on separate lines?
New Jersey's home improvement rules cover painting, repairing and restoring a home (N.J.A.C. 13:45A-16.1A). Any guarantee or warranty has to be given to you in writing, with its exclusions, when the bid is presented and again when the contract is signed; a contract over $500, and every change to it, has to be in writing and signed (N.J.A.C. 13:45A-16.2(a)11 and 12). You can also check a New Jersey contractor's registration.
Where we refinish tubs and tile
From our office at 65 Newark Ave, Unit 1 in Belleville, across all 22 Essex County towns: Belleville, Bloomfield, Glen Ridge, East Orange, Nutley, Orange, Montclair, Newark, West Orange, Verona, Irvington, South Orange, Cedar Grove, Essex Fells, Maplewood, Caldwell, North Caldwell, Roseland, West Caldwell, Livingston, Millburn, Fairfield. We also work in Union and Passaic counties.


